So wow, this is kind of a hard book review to do right now with all the controversy surrounding
Breaking Dawn going on in our blogosphere. I have very mixed feelings about the book. I am still a Twi-hard and will reread the first 3 A LOT I'm sure! I guess though that I have to admit I did not
love the story of
Breaking Dawn as much as the other books. It seemed a little random and bizarre. It felt rushed in parts and so slow in others. So I guess what I'm saying is that it did not
flow very well to me.
I was so not expecting Nessie (I refuse to write her other name because it is just that horrible!!!). For me it was like throwing a love child into the story of Romeo and Juliet. Who wants that?? I'm far more interested in Edward and Bella so dealing with them as sudden parents was a bit off putting to me. I know, I know, it made it so that Bella could become a vampire as a last resort and helped her not to have to give up having children to be with Edward.... I understand why SM wrote it this way, that doesn't mean I have to love it, right? Maybe if they seemed more like a happy little nuclear family it would have been easier for me, but it seemed like Edward was not as involved as he should have been and that both Edward and Bella kind of pawned off the responsibility of caring for Nessie on the rest of the family and Jacob. I think if SM would have taken more time developing the story of their new little family and less on the truly disturbing pregnancy it would have been loads better. And then the whole imprinting thing is very icky to me. I had problems with the ages of couples in
The Host and I continue to think the age thing in SM's books is "out there".
My major beef with the book was that there was just not enough Edward. I don't know why Jacob got an entire section in his point of view and not Edward. What's up with that?? I want to know what Edward was thinking when he offered Bella to Jacob so that they could have a non-monster baby. That just seemed so truly out of character for Edward. I know he will give Bella pretty much anything she wants, but in the other books he stood his moral ground more. I guess in the face of Bella's imminent death things changed, but in
Eclipse he was so good... Anyway I still love Edward. He is an amazing character and I'm so glad SM thought him up. I just wish the
Breaking Dawn Edward was more of the Edward that I knew from the last 3 books. I really can't wait for her to finish
Midnight Sun!! (Seriously though I kind of hope she takes her time with it so that the writing is a bit better.)
Oh and far outweighing any adversion I had to the sex (which I was not that offended by as a 30 year old woman) or violence was Jasper's new nickname!!! Jazz??? Now that bothered me!!!:)
So here's what I loved:
Absolutely my favorite part was Bella's first hunt as a vampire! I am a fanpire in general, so I've read my fair share of "newborn vampire" scenes in different books. My all time favorite new vampire scene is from
Interview with a Vampire were Louis cannot stop looking at the brass button on Lestat's waistcoat because it is more beautiful through the eyes of a vampire than he could have imagined possible. Anne Rice's imagery was down right stunning in that scene. So like that I was all into Bella figuring out just how powerful and cool she was and seeing things through her new uber-vampire eyes. I thought the way that she saw Jasper for the first time through vampire eyes was very interesting and creative on the part of Stephenie Meyer. I never thought of Jasper as a thoroughly chewed up vampire (even though it was mentioned in the last book) so seeing him like that made me appreciate all the newborn vampire stuff from
Eclipse more. I loved the way everyone was afraid of Bella for no reason and her amazing self-control as a newborn (of course it was convenient for SM to write it like that since we experience everything through Bella's eyes and it would have been too bizarre to see everything through a crazed newborn psycho vampire's eyes).
Another thing I loved about the book.... Stefan and Vlad! Oh those Romanian vampires!!! I just thought that was awesome even though it was a bit cliche. I just imagined them as twin Draculas and appreciated SM throwing them in at the end for a bit of comic relief for us Dracula fans out there!
The last favorite part I will mention is a part that many out there loved, the way that Bella allowed Edward to read her mind in that last scene. I thought that was beautiful and found it a lovely way to end the saga.
So that was my mixed and muddled review. I hope you were able to follow me through that. I am still a Twi-hard and a Fanpire through and through. I will always love
Twilight the best just because of how I related to Bella in that book - I moved half way through my junior year of high school and reading that was like a blast from the past. Well without the whole uber-vampire falling in love with me part. My goodness how in heaven I would have been if Edward showed up at PGHS!!! I seriously can't wait for the
Twilight movie to come out!! It's sure to be awesome!!